In brief
PAS 9980 calls for professional judgement, so two competent assessors can rate the same walls differently. Start by comparing what each one saw and assumed, not just their conclusions. A second opinion from a qualified professional, a question to the assessor's professional body, or a funded scheme's audit can settle it.
It happens more than people expect. One assessor says the walls are acceptable with better management; another says they need remediation. For the building owner, the residents and anyone trying to sell, it is a confusing place to be.
Why it happens
PAS 9980 is a risk-based method, not a test with a fixed pass mark. The government’s step-by-step guide says placing a building in a risk category is necessarily subjective and needs professional judgement. Differences usually come from:
- What each assessor saw: one opened up the wall, the other relied on drawings
- What they assumed: about the insulation, cavity barriers or fire stopping they couldn’t see
- How they weighed other measures: sprinklers, alarms and how the building is managed
- When they looked: works or new information between the two appraisals
Compare the reasoning, not the verdict
Put the two reports side by side and list, for each wall type, what was found, what was assumed and why. Often one report was based on better information, and that settles it. If both are well founded and still differ, the gap is in judgement, and you need a way to resolve it.
Ways to resolve it
- Ask each assessor to respond in writing to the other’s reasoning
- Commission a third, independent opinion from a qualified professional, as the government guide suggests
- If you think a report falls short, raise it with the assessor’s professional body
- If the building is in the Cladding Safety Scheme, the scheme audits FRAEWs against PAS 9980 before an application goes forward
The gov.uk FRAEW collection was updated in November 2026 with information on what happens when two FRAEWs reach different conclusions. Read it before deciding.
Tell residents
Residents may have heard about both reports. Tell them plainly what each found, what you are doing to resolve the difference, and what interim steps are in place.
Need a further opinion? We can find an independent assessor through FRAEW quotes. See also choosing an assessor and PAS 9980 assessment.